EN
18 November 2026 - 18:24 AMT

Armenian journalism groups demand withdrawal of defamation bill

Nine Armenian journalism organizations have called on the Ministry of Justice to withdraw proposed amendments introducing minimum monetary compensation of AMD 1 million for insult and AMD 2 million for defamation, warning that the measures could threaten freedom of expression and critical reporting.

The draft would establish these minimum thresholds alongside the existing maximum compensation limits of AMD 3 million and AMD 6 million, respectively. If adopted, plaintiffs would be unable to seek compensation below the prescribed minimums, while courts would be prevented from awarding smaller amounts.

In a joint statement, the organizations warned against allowing liability mechanisms for insult and defamation to become instruments of pressure on the media.

They cited the case law of the European Court of Human Rights and Decision No. 997 of Armenia’s Constitutional Court, emphasizing that courts must consider a media outlet’s financial circumstances when determining compensation to ensure that liability does not lead to bankruptcy.

According to the signatories, years of monitoring litigation against journalists and media outlets have shown that plaintiffs generally did not challenge compensation awards of AMD 200,000–300,000. They therefore questioned the need for additional state regulation and the introduction of elements resembling criminal penalties into a civil compensation mechanism.

The organizations stressed that they were not seeking to protect individuals responsible for insult or defamation.

The Ministry of Justice argues that the amendments are intended to strengthen protection of honor, dignity, business reputation and other fundamental rights, as the current framework does not adequately guarantee compensation proportionate to the harm caused.

However, the signatories said the proposal failed to address cases in which politicians, senior officials and other public figures treat legitimate criticism as insult or defamation and pursue legal action to “punish” media outlets.

They argued that insufficient judicial independence and politically motivated rulings by some judges have allowed such practices to persist, and that the proposed amendments could make them easier to pursue.

Although the ministry has stated that not every instance of insult or defamation should automatically result in financial compensation, the organizations consider this an insufficient safeguard against financial pressure on the press.

The signatories called on the Ministry of Justice to withdraw the draft amendments to the Civil Code and initiate open professional discussions with media representatives on the justification for the proposal and the need to strengthen liability for insult and defamation.

They also urged the ministry to submit the draft to the Council of Europe and other international bodies for expert assessment of its compliance with European standards.

The statement was signed by the Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression, Yerevan Press Club, Media Initiatives Center, Institute for War and Peace Reporting – Armenia, Asparez Journalists’ Club, Public Journalism Club, Journalists for the Future NGO, Journalists for Human Rights NGO and Freedom of Information Center.

On November 16, the Ministry of Justice submitted the draft amendments to the Civil Code for public consultation. The proposal concerns monetary compensation for insult and defamation under Article 1087.1.